Advertisement

5 Angels players who've already proven they don't belong on roster after May 1

Might not be too much longer until these guys are not wearing Angels unis every night
Evan Roberts
Evan Roberts

Halo Hangout

Cleveland Guardians v Los Angeles Angels / Luke Hales/GettyImages

It's great seeing the Angels play winning baseball, eh? Halos players are showing fans who have stuck by them something worth watching right now...well, not all of them. It's pretty impossible for every member of the 26-man roster on the right track at the same time, and it's no different for Angels as it is for any winning team.

Whether it's having a superior prospect/rehabbing major league player in the minor leagues, or the player was recently picked up and expendable, there are five notable players who could might need to be expelled from the roster come May (this is a relatively tough exercise, the roster looks awesome overall).

5 Angels players who've already proven they don't belong on roster after May 1

Neto's Replacements: Nicky Lopez and Kevin Newman

Lopez was acquired more as insurance for the Angels' third base platoon of Yoán Moncada and Luis Rengifo while they work their way back from their respective injuries, but he is basically keeping Neto's roster spot warm for him while he rehabs. However, there's a scenario where Moncada and Rengifo never really are able to stay healthy (Moncada was removed from the second game of the series vs. Tampa due to his lingering thumb injury), and Lopez just sticks on the team. The glove-first utility man has predictably struggled with getting playing time and being productive when he does play.

The difference between Lopez's struggles at the plate and Newman's is one can claim that Lopez has barely had a sample size. Newman has nearly triple the amount of plate appearances this year as Lopez, but just one more hit. His defense has been stellar -- he leads the Angels in defensive fWAR thus far -- but it's been looking real bad at the plate.

Newman, Lopez, and one player we are about to get to here playing solid-to-stellar defense but not hitting a lick is not the Angels' worst case scenario as they await Neto's return, but they sure could use another bopper in the lineup surrounding Ward, Schanuel, Trout, Soler, O'Hoppe, Paris, and Rengifo.

The Anderson Trio

On Ian:

Some things to like with Ian:

  • If he can throw mostly changeups, he might become an entirely new pitcher. He still seems too much like a starter, and not enough of a reliever. Make him into Chris Devenski or Tommy Kahnle and he might thrive.
  • He is not allowing a lot of hard contact even with the brutal traditional stats. He has a staggeringly low 3.30 xFIP despite his .400 batting average against.
  • He's still only 26-years-old.

Some things to not like with Ian:

  • 2.50 WHIP, worst on the entire Angels staff.
  • Are we sure we like Anderson because of who he is, or is he just not José Suarez?

On Tim:

Including Timmy A on this list is tougher than adding the other four members, as he came into this season running faster and has made a few miraculous plays in the infield. However, it's the same thing as with Newman and Lopez, he is just an automatic out at the plate right now. Sure, he's not as atrocious as Lopez or Newman, but it's still a .154/.185/.192/.377 slash line with an .038 ISO, .29.6% K%, and 3.7% BB%.

In an ideal lineup, Moncada, Neto, Rengifo, and Schanuel are in the infield, then you can start Adell in centerfield, and Paris in either centerfield or at second base. A second base platoon of Rengifo and Paris seems favorable than a duo that includes T.A., and this is before you even factor in promoting a player from the minors. Imagine if Christian Moore starts raking and showing defensive improvements this month...

On Tyler:

He's posted some pretty awful results. In his two starts, he has a 7.38 FIP (5.86 xFIP, which is still horrible), a 5.40 BB/9, allowed three home runs, and his metrics are very subpar. Could the Angels save some money by moving off his expiring contract, and use the savings to actually extend a member of their young core of future stars? Is that at all possible? If yes, sooner the better. Give Kyren Paris $300 MM already...

More LA Angels News from Halo Hangout

Evan Roberts

Evan Roberts

Evan Roberts worked in professional baseball for 5 years, after pitching collegiately at Davidson College for 4. After graduating in 2018, he worked with the Boston Red Sox at their Pawtucket affiliate for the 2019 season as a Player Development Intern. He picked up with the Chicago White Sox in 2020, but after the Minor League season was canceled he worked with Team USA Baseball at their National Training Complex as a Trackman Stringer/Operator. From 2021-2023, he worked with the Los Angeles Angels as a Game Planning Strategist at their Arizona (ROK League), Salt Lake (AAA), Rocket City (AA) affiliates. He attended the Angels' last 2 Major League Spring Trainings. During Rookie Ball games, he coached 1st base and assisted the players & coaches in the dugout.