Advertisement

The dream Angels roster if/when they do not add another player this offseason

Evan Roberts
Evan Roberts

Halo Hangout

Los Angeles Angels v Minnesota Twins / Stephen Maturen/GettyImages

It sure looks like the Angels' roster is finalized. The team is likely done spending money, even if it's for a cheap reliever. Arte Moreno does not want to potentially lose 1.25% of his net worth rather than 1% by investing more money into the 2025 Los Angeles Angels -- who are looking to bounce-back from their franchise nadir in 2024.

“I was not interested in spending $200 million,” Moreno said. “We needed too many things to spend $200 million.” The team currently is looking at a $202 million payroll, compared to the $215 million payroll they had in 2023. They have $20 million they could spend before they get to the luxury tax to fit in a bona fide stud like David Robertson, but Moreno might have closed up shop for the winter.

With that in mind, how could the Angels perfectly construct their team for Opening Day?

In a perfect world, Zach Neto will be fully healthy by Opening Day so he can build off of his stellar 2024 campaign. He is progressing slightly in his throwing program and is hitting off a tee, but he obviously has a long ways to go before he is fully right. The Angels are not putting a timetable on his return, as they do not want to rush him back to the field before he is 100% right. Neto will likely be delayed in his return to the Angels lineup, but let's say his shoulder is healed and pencil him in. We can dream, can't we?

The dream Angels lineup for Opening Day

vs. RHPs:
1. Soler—DH
2. Trout—9
3. Neto—6
4. Ward—7
5. Moncada**—5
6. O’Hoppe—2
7. Schanuel*—3
8. Moore—4
9. Moniak*—8

Bench: Adell, Newman, d’Arnaud, Rengifo**

* -- left-handed hitter
** -- switch-hitter

vs. LHPs:
1. Soler—DH
2. Trout—9
3. Neto—6
4. Ward—7
5. d'Arnaud—2
6. Rengifo**—5
7. Adell—8
8. Moore—4
9. Schanuel*—3

Bench: Moniak*, Newman, O'Hoppe, Moncada**

* -- left-handed hitter
** -- switch-hitter

That's right, let's get Christian Moore in there every day! Moore making the team would bump out guys like Niko Kavadas (Newman can operate as Schanuel's backup first baseman, he has experience there from last season), Scott Kingery, and Tim Anderson. If Moore does end up tearing up spring training and making the roster, he has to play every day for his development. In no way should he be a part-time player at the big league level at this point in his career.

Moore making the team in this dream scenario essentially pushes Rengifo and Moncada into a platoon at third base, which feels absolutely necessary given both of their injury histories. Like with Logan O'Hoppe and Travis d'Arnaud, Rengifo and Moncada have notable splits against left-handed and right-handed pitchers:

Rengifo's career wRC+ as a RHH vs. LHPs: 111
Rengifo's career wRC+ as a LHH vs. RHPs: 87
Moncada's career wRC+ as a LHH vs. RHPs: 110
Moncada's career wRC+ as a RHH vs. LHPs: 96

Jorge Soler is an atypical but ideal leadoff hitter. It's hard to ignore his career statistics batting no. 1 in the order, and the Angels likely want to avoid using Neto, Schanuel, or Moore there. Ron Washington noted Soler could slide down to cleanup, but if he is in the top three he has to be leadoff.

The Moniak and Adell platoon in centerfield is looking like a lock at this point, with Trout moving over to right. Ideally, the Angels can pull off a trade for Luis Robert Jr. to play every day in center...but we digress.

The dream Angels pitching staff for Opening Day

Starting Rotation: 
1. Kikuchi*
2. Soriano
3. Anderson*
4. Kochanowicz
5. Detmers*

* -- left-handed pitcher

Bullpen:
Closer: Jansen
Set-Up: Joyce 
Middle Relief: Burke*, Zeferjahn, Quijada*
Swing: Silseth, McDaniels* 
Long: Hendricks

* -- left-handed pitcher

Yeah yeah, Perry Minasian said Hendricks is a lock for the rotation. Understood. However, in a dream world, Hendricks is relegated to a long reliever role given the upside Kochanowicz and Detmers could provide. At this stage in their careers, Hendricks has the higher floor (especially compared to Detmers) but Kochanowicz and Detmers unequivocally have the higher ceilings if they can put a few pieces together in camp. Their stuff is just far more electrifying, and Hendricks plays far better as a long reliever/emergency starter moving forward.

Other than Hendricks moving to long relief, there are no real surprises here with the pitching staff. Angels fans should keep a close eye on Garrett McDaniels this spring. If he does not make the Opening Day roster, then the Angels likely lose the asset by forfeiting him back to the Dodgers. He has 0 pedigree at the major league level, but the Angels can sneak him onto the team and ease him in with some low-leverage situations in order to maximize their courses of action this season. He has good stuff and would fit in nicely with Chase Silseth as swing guys in that bullpen.

In this construction of the 40-man roster, José Suarez would need to get DFA'd since he is out of minor league options. Another dream scenario for Angels fans. McDaniels can take Sam Bachman's spot on the team, as Bachman is still ramping up his workload this spring. He can take Hans Crouse's as well, since he has a MiLB option left.

More LA Angels News from Halo Hangout

Evan Roberts

Evan Roberts

Evan Roberts worked in professional baseball for 5 years, after pitching collegiately at Davidson College for 4. After graduating in 2018, he worked with the Boston Red Sox at their Pawtucket affiliate for the 2019 season as a Player Development Intern. He picked up with the Chicago White Sox in 2020, but after the Minor League season was canceled he worked with Team USA Baseball at their National Training Complex as a Trackman Stringer/Operator. From 2021-2023, he worked with the Los Angeles Angels as a Game Planning Strategist at their Arizona (ROK League), Salt Lake (AAA), Rocket City (AA) affiliates. He attended the Angels' last 2 Major League Spring Trainings. During Rookie Ball games, he coached 1st base and assisted the players & coaches in the dugout.