The Los Angeles Angels were one of the biggest winners at the 2026 trade deadline. The infusion of talent that John Mozeliak's wheelings and dealings brought in on top of a stellar draft class set the scene for the Angels' farm system to rise greatly in terms of talent, depth, and perception.
One of those trades that looked like an instant win was the deal that sent Jo Adell to the Cleveland Guardians in exchange for catching prospect Jacob Cozart. Unfortunately, Adell hadn't quite built upon his powerful 2025 campaign, hitting just .239/.287/.395 and putting up a below-average 91 wRC+ at the time of the trade.
With the clock ticking on Adell's team control and the threat of him getting more expensive with his second pass through arbitration, getting anything of value was a win. Cozart looked like a glove-first catcher, but he was considered to have starter upside, making it look like a better-than-expected return.
One of the appeals that Adell offered, aside from the ability to occasionally hit the ball a long way, was team control through the 2027 season. Apparently, the Guardians are ready to throw that down the drain, with the 27-year-old outfielder being named a prime non-tender candidate ahead of the November 20 deadline.
The funniest thing about that is the fact that Adell was better with Cleveland than he was in Los Angeles. Over 48 games with the Guardians, he hit .244/.324/.417 with seven homers and a 107 wRC+.
The Guardians non-tendering Adell would solidify the Angels' trade win, give LA a chance to reunite with the outfielder
Just as Adell improved with the Guardians, so did Cozart once he hit the Angels' system. Now the Halos' No. 22 prospect, Cozart went from posting a .239/.330/.384 with 10 homers over 79 games in Double-A in Cleveland's system to recording a .248/.356/.475 line with seven dingers over just 28 contests.
Cozart draws rave reviews for his receiving and framing, as well as his communication and leadership with the pitching staff. On top of that, he has a rocket arm. If he starts hitting for power the way he did once Los Angeles acquired him, he could really be something.
At the same time, if Cleveland non-tenders Adell, it would represent them admitting defeat. The Guardians got him because they needed right-handed pop, and that still hasn't changed. Parting ways with the former top prospect would be making a statement that they don't believe he's good enough to help them in an area where they are very deficient. Giving up a real asset and then not taking advantage of everything you received in return is a real loss.
Jo Adell on his time with the Angels:
— SleeperAngels (@SleeperAngels) August 24, 2026
“I turned into a man and a big leaguer in the Angels organization. I got a chance to grow up and find who I was as a player. It’s really a full-circle moment to be here and be on the other side and playing this group.”
(@RhettBollinger) pic.twitter.com/0zQ3Y5Zbik
The funniest part of it all is that if Cleveland non-tenders Adell, he'd become a free agent and the Angels could theoretically sign him. Los Angeles has needs all over the place, and while center field is a more pressing issue (and we know Adell can't handle the position), Adell returning would allow the club to DH Mike Trout more and give Wade Meckler a chance to play left field, where his defensive skills profile better.
If the Angels get Adell back plus a meaningful prospect for simply allowing the Guardians to rent him for two months, the trade will be remembered as one of the greatest heists in franchise history.
