Current Lineup vs. RHPs:
1. Soler—DH
2. Trout—8
3. Schanuel*—3
4. Ward—7
5. O’Hoppe—2
6. Rengifo**—4
7. Rendon—5
8. Newman—6
9. Moniak*—9
Bench: Adell, Kingery, d’Arnaud, Kavadas*
Injured List: Neto
* -- left-handed hitter
** -- switch-hitter
Ideal Lineup vs. RHPs:
1. Soler—DH
2. Trout—7
3. Schanuel*—3
4. Eugenio Suárez—5 -- acquire via trade alongside Alek Thomas for Rengifo, Moniak, & Bachman
5. Ward—9
6. O’Hoppe—2
7. Alek Thomas*—8 -- acquire via trade alongside Eugenio Suárez
8. Moore—4
9. Newman—6
Bench: Adell, Kingery, d’Arnaud, Kavadas*
Injured List: Neto
* -- left-handed hitter
In: Eugenio Suárez, Alek Thomas, Christian Moore
Despite a down year across the board in 2024, Alek Thomas is a good bounce-back and change of scenery bet for the Angels. Moniak has been better than Thomas the past two seasons, but Thomas' ceiling still looks higher given the soon-to-be 25-year-old centerfielder's Gold Glove-quality defense, athleticism, speed, and raw power. Moniak's floor is higher in 2025, but Thomas' ceiling is higher if he can stay healthy (Moniak also has a relatively long list of injuries).
Pushing Christian Moore is relatively divisive amongst Angels fans. Why stop pushing prospects now, though? Even if/when he struggles at the beginning of the season, adding Moore as a power-hitting second baseman at the bottom of the lineup could provide the team with a spark when they enter the dog-days of the summer.
Out: Luis Rengifo, Mickey Moniak, Anthony Rendon
Any scenario where the Angels cut Anthony Rendon and eat his remaining $76 million is a dream scenario for Angels fans. Losing Rengifo is difficult, but Suárez is a clear upgrade for the Angels who desperately needs more sluggers.