Angels roster projections 2.0: Who makes the Opening Day roster?
The Los Angeles Angels have played a full week of games. It's so nice to have baseball back, and Opening Day really can't come soon enough. With a week of games under our belt, it's time to revisit our Opening Day roster projections.
A lot has happened since our first predictions were released. The Angels have made a signing, and we've seen how players have performed early on in the spring.
There will definitely be some surprises on the actual Opening Day roster, and injuries (fingers crossed) are impossible to predict. Let's see what our latest Los Angeles Angels Opening Day roster predictions look like.
Angels 2023 Opening Day roster predictions: Two-way players (1)
Shohei Ohtani
Shohei Ohtani is headed to the WBC. It'll be fun to watch him on the big stage. He swung the bat well and showed that the pitch clock will be no bother in the regular season. He looks ready to capture his second AL MVP award.
Angels 2023 Opening Day roster predictions: Starting pitchers (5+Ohtani)
Tyler Anderson, Patrick Sandoval, Reid Detmers, Jose Suarez, Tucker Davidson
Nothing has changed for the top five in this rotation, and nothing will change barring injury (again, fingers crossed). Shohei Ohtani is the ace, Tyler Anderson looked good in his debut, Sandoval and Detmers are both coming on strong, and Suarez will hopefully get off to a good start in 2023.
The sixth spot is where things change from the first edition of the predictions. I have Tucker Davidson making the roster over Griffin Canning.
Canning hasn't pitched yet, but is scheduled to go on Monday. It'll be his first start since July of 2021, and a huge start for him to show the Angels where he is physically.
I believe Canning will have a long way to go to build up to a starter's workload, and the Angels (should) build him up slowly. With that in mind, Canning being ready in a little bit over three weeks doesn't seem possible.
If Canning isn't ready, I believe the sixth starter spot is a competition between three different pitchers: Jaime Barria, Chase Silseth, and Tucker Davidson. As you can see, the answer I came up with was Davidson.
Neither of the three pitchers listed have excelled in their outings. Silseth allowed two runs in two innings, Barria allowed four runs in two innings, and Davidson, after a good first start, allowed two runs in two innings in his second start.
The reason I went with Davidson is strictly because he's looked the best of the three, and he's out of options. Unless someone sticks out, it's hard to pick any of the others for this spot over Davidson for that reason alone. Silseth wasn't effective in his brief stints with the Angels last season. Barria excelled as a reliever. It's what makes sense unless Canning comes back strong or someone else excells.
Angels 2023 Opening Day roster predictions: Starting lineup (8 +Ohtani)
Taylor Ward, Mike Trout, Anthony Rendon, Hunter Renfroe, Jared Walsh, Brandon Drury, Logan O'Hoppe, David Fletcher
Same lineup, why not. The Angels have swung the bat really well in the spring, and this is still how I think they should line up.
The only spots up for debate are catcher and shortstop. Max Stassi hasn't played a game yet, but we know he'll be on the roster in some shape or form, either starting a majority of the games or serving as the backup catcher.
The other catcher spot is between Matt Thaiss and Logan O'Hoppe. Both catchers have one hit in six at-bats, but the result of their hits shows who has the better potential. Thaiss singled, O'Hoppe hit a booming opposite field home run. Oh, and let's not forget this throw either. Things won't be perfect with O'Hoppe who's far from complete, but he's better than Thaiss.
Shortstop can be played by a slew of Angels players, none of them would be the most ideal option in the world. I lean Fletcher because of his glove. I'd understand Rengifo, I'd understand Urshela, but with how important defense is at the position, I lean Fletch. All three will see time anyway.
Angels 2023 Opening Day roster predictions: Bench (4)
Max Stassi, Gio Urshela, Luis Rengifo, Brett Phillips
The bench remains the same as well. Stassi is going to play a decent amount regardless, one I lean O'Hoppe over Thaiss so we don't have to see Stassi get a starters load.
Urshela is good enough to start, but is a third baseman. The Angels have a third baseman. When that third baseman gets hurt, Urshela will play there every day. Until that happens, he'll play all over the infield. He should play four or five times a week, just won't have a designated starting role on Opening Day.
Rengifo is in a similar boat as Urshela. I hope the Angels use him against southpaws because of how lethal he was against them last season, but will see time all over the place. We even saw him play right field in a Spring Training game. The Angels have a ton of depth.
Brett Philips hasn't done much of anything offensively in the spring which is disappointing, but expected. He is practically a lock to make the Opening Day roster because the Angels gave him an MLB contract.
Phillips hopefully won't be asked to hit too much, but should provide a spark in the clubhouse, on the bases, and in the field. He's better in his role than someone like Adell or Moniak who should be playing every day in the minors. If an outfielder gets hurt, the Angels will call up one of those guys to play every day.
Angels 2023 Opening Day roster predictions: Bullpen (8)
Carlos Estevez, Jimmy Herget, Matt Moore, Aaron Loup, Ryan Tepera, Jaime Barria, Jose Quijada, Andrew Wantz
The addition to the Angels bullpen that they really needed was Matt Moore. Moore is coming off of a dominant season with Texas. While repeating that season feels unlikely, he's certainly an upgrade over Zack Weiss who was in my first projection.
Estevez and Herget will join Moore as late-game high-leverage arms Phil Nevin can turn to. If the Angels do name a closer it'll likely be Estevez, but all three will pitch big innings and will be key pieces to the Angels success in 2023.
Loup and Tepera are obviously locks to make the team as they're established veterans making a lot of money. Hopefully both can pitch a bit better than they did last season.
Jose Quijada had a nice year in 2022 and is the third lefty in this bullpen. He has the good fastball, with him it's about finding a second pitch that works and limiting walks.
Andrew Wantz is the only guy in this bullpen who doesn't feel like a lock, but should make the team. He was really solid for the Halos last season.
This bullpen with Moore in it looks so much better than it did in the first projections. Hopefully Estevez and Barria will pitch better than they have this spring.