The Los Angeles Angels and free agency aren't things that go together very well. Nearly every big-name free-agent signing that the Angels have made — Anthony Rendon, Josh Hamilton, C.J. Wilson, and Albert Pujols — are prime examples of aggressive, big-money deals that have gone awry.
After being shell-shocked so many times, Arte Moreno has pulled back the reins, and the Angels have become much more conservative. We don't often see Los Angeles making big splashes early, with the signing of Yusei Kikuchi at the end of November in 2024 serving as the lone semi-notable example.
For the most part, the Halos wait for the market to develop, and then they wait some more. Once the financial Goliaths have had their fill, in come the Angels to pick clean the bones with signings like Yoan Moncada on a one-year deal.
With new leadership in the front office in place, we're hoping for a change in strategy. We've seen the changes John Mozeliak has implemented in the handling of prospect development and the draft, already paying dividends for the farm system. But this is one area where Moreno will have a lot to say.
The insiders are already predicting that we'll see more of the same. That's bad enough as it is, but if the latest MLB owners' CBA proposal comes to fruition, it will make free agency that much worse for the Angels.
Angels' free agency strategy will become even less effective if MLB owners' CBA proposal comes to fruition
Compared to the NFL and the NBA, the MLB offseason is a long, drawn-out process. Many of the big names move at a glacial pace when it comes to finding a new home, and the mid-tier players behind them wait for the frontline talent to set the market. Apparently, the owners don't want that anymore.
Instead, they'd prefer a feeding-frenzy style. The kind where it starts with a bang and then quickly fizzles out. Per ESPN's Jesse Rogers, the league has proposed a three-week free-agency window that would begin at the beginning of December and then close on December 21.
From there, no signings would be allowed until the first Monday in February before spring training. That would cut out a large part of the transactional real estate, one that, if the Angels were smart, they could have used to their advantage.
If this happens, the likely outcome is that the top stars signing quicker. They'll get the same money, more or less, but there will be less haggling over perks and opt-outs and such. That will then have the spotlight quickly focused on the second-tier player, and it will continue to be a fast and furious process.
Under the current structure, you often find those next-level players having to settle for pillow contracts and one-year deals because the market has never developed for them. The Angels haven't really played in this area, mostly because they haven't been good enough for any of these guys to make a difference, but theoretically, this would be an area that Moreno would feel comfortable breaking out the crowbar to pry open his wallet.
However, if everything is condensed, that likely doesn't happen. Sure, the players have less time to hold out for a good deal, but at the same time, teams have needs, and if they don't act fast, they risk being locked out of being able to fill them. That means that the second-tier free agent is now getting a market-value contract, and the prices will go up.
We're still a long way away from anything being settled, but this is one to monitor. It could create a dire situation where Moreno's timidness to spend is exacerbated and hurts the Angels greatly.
