Angels' decision to not trade Reid Detmers just provided clue to team's next steps

The Los Angeles Angels, in the recent past, became notorious for believing that selling was the worst thing they could do, which is why this year’s trade deadline was almost unrecognizable. Logan O’Hoppe and Chase Silseth were traded with years of control remaining. So were Jose Soriano and Jo Adell and Ryan Zeferjahn. Add in the Brent Suter deal, and the Angels made five trades with five different partners and now have a farm system with real names in it, headlined by shortstop Arjun Nimmala. 

Then there’s Reid Detmers, still an Angel.

For a few minutes, it looked like he had been traded to the Cubs in a deal built around prospect Jefferson Rojas. But whether that deal ever actually lived, it was dead pretty quickly. Chicago pivoted to Miami for Braxton Garrett and ended up coming back to the Angels for Zeferjahn while Detmers stayed home.

Maybe the negotiation didn’t come together. Maybe it was something else. But if the Angels were truly committed to tearing this thing all the way down, there’s no way he survives a deadline where they moved so many pieces. He just turned 27, is controllable for two more years after this one, and has shown that the move back to the rotation was a good one. It sure looks like the Angels are betting on Detmers as a centerpiece now rather than someone who can bring back more for the future.

The Angels sell-off is over, and that tells you what comes next

The message here is that they’re done selling. It’s not because the Angels ran out of players to trade. They still have some who other clubs will want this offseason. It’s because they ended up making a clear distinction between keep and sell, and Detmers was fully in that first list. Whether that stems from a negotiation gone wrong or that they determined they needed someone to build around in the rotation, it’s a declaration of what the next era in Anaheim will look like.

That extends to the winter too. They just spent the deadline restocking their system with honest-to-goodness talent. That probably means they aren’t going to turn around and give out nine figures to someone who blocks one of their new prospects. The return from this deadline was never really about win-now upgrades. It was about collecting the next wave.

Pairing that with keeping Detmers says that ownership and the front office are aligned on letting internal options play for now. But it also says that maybe they don’t expect this rebuild to take forever. They can absolutely still trade Detmers at a later date, but they’re betting on a rotation headed by him and Walbert Ureña to help usher in a new era. Keeping Detmers is one spot they don’t need to search for now over the next couple of years.

That’s why the offseason won’t be quiet. The Angels still have real needs, and this front office has now earned a little credibility by actually following through on a sell-off that should have happened years ago. But what follows figures to be more around the margins to be good enough to win now while waiting for what they hope is a brighter future. 

Detmers staying put isn’t a footnote on deadline day. It’s sort of the whole thesis for how the next few months of Angels baseball will look. They don’t need to find someone to paper over a hole at the top of their rotation. They’ve got Detmers for that. They can develop their young talent, add pieces around them, and stop trying to buy their way out of a rebuild before it’s finished.

That feels so different than the past. The Angels may be big-money shoppers, but it feels like, for the first time in a long time, there’s an actual plan behind the moves. And there’s also a plan behind the moves they didn’t make.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow